Poppy Playtime has had a surprising amount of longevity. Ever since the first chapter of the game was released in 2021, these games have been the focus of the modern mascot horror subgenre of gaming and are even receiving afilm adaptation. With the recent release of Chapter 4 coming and going, fans have been craving more games like them to play.
7 Best Horror Games To Play in the Dark
Could I get some more nighttime with my horror game, please?
If you’re a fan of games like Poppy Playtime, then you’re in luck as there is no shortage of similar games to play. The mascot horror genre has grown a lot in the last decade, making it quite easy to provide the following list of games that play very similar to Poppy.
10Garten of BanBan
Bait for the Young
Euphoric Brothers
Release Date
July 18, 2025
PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, PC
2023’s Garten of Banban is the perfect example of how an indie mascot horror game can quickly become a household name. In the little bit over a year since this game was released, the developers were able to churn out over eight sequels to the title and a countless amount of merchandise.
If you are a fan of Poppy Playtime, then you may enjoy Garten of Banban’s short chapters, strange explorable facilities, and unique designs for the monsters that will chase you down hallways. While it is undeniably extremely popular, Garten of Banban falls at the bottom of this list due to the actual games feeling extremely low quality at this point. Even die-hard fans of the mascot horror subgenre have expressed distaste for this game, with claims that it brings the whole genre’s reputation down. With that kind of online discourse, it would be hard to consider ranking it higher than this.
9Rainbow Friends
Horrifying Colors
Developers
Ray & Charcle
July 19, 2025
As the mascot horror subgenre has been targeting younger and younger audiences in recent years, a surprising amount of them have been developed inside of the free-to-play platform Roblox. One such title is Rainbow Friends, a multiplayer game where players must collect items while avoiding colorful monsters that will chase them down. Similar to titles like Poppy Playtime and Garten of Banban, the game has been slowly releasing itself in chapters that have varying content.
In many ways, Poppy Playtime and Rainbow Friends have had a similar existence. Both seemed to blow up in popularity overnight as horror content creators played them and various merchandising companies began making plushes of their monsters. Despite this, Rainbow Friends ranks low on this list as, for many, it embodies the problems that currently plague the subgenre, like a focus on commercialization and dragging younger children into it.
8Hello Neighbor
A Forgotten Trailblazer
Eerie Guest Studios
July 20, 2025
Xbox One, PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Android, PC
OpenCritic Score
During the mid-2010s, most mascot horror games tried to gimmick the FNAF gameplay loop and formula of having the player try to survive in a single location for an extended period of time. Then,Hello Neighborcame along and introduced the world to the currently popular chase-formula of the subgenre, where the player must navigate their way through a colorful location and solve puzzles as a monster slowly closes in on them. Future games with this gameplay loop, like Poppy Playtime, owe their existence to Hello Neighbor.
10 Most Terrifying Animatronics in the Five Nights at Freddy’s Series
It’s time to meet the most terrifying animatronics in the Five Nights at Freddy’s series.
Despite its initial popularity, frequentconsole ports, and how it helped set the stage for games like Poppy Playtime, Hello Neighbor has earned the scorn of many in the community due to its bizarre game/puzzle designs, rushed-out spin-off titles which didn’t capture the magic of the first game, and overall not living up to its potential.
7Bendy and the Ink Machine
Blotting Out Hope
Joey Drew Studios
June 03, 2025
PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Android, IOS, Nintendo Switch, PC
When games like Five Nights at Freddy’s and Hello Neighbor were at their peak, there was another horror title trying to make a name for itself with a unique setting and art style: Bendy and the Ink Machine. This game, set in an abandoned animation studio, was filled with dark parodies of old rubber hose cartoon icons which filled children who played it with fear.
In many ways, Poppy Playtime feels directly inspired by Bendy and the Ink Machine. From taking place in an abandoned location designed to create children’s entertainment, a twisted version of the mascot of said company, and even some of the puzzles and level design in later chapters of Poppy feel like they could belong directly in the Bendy games. If you are a fan of Poppy Playtime and want another, very similar, game to play through; the Bendy franchise is awaiting your download.
6Tattletail
Gracefully Bowed Out
Waygetter Electronics
Little Flag Software
August 16, 2025
If you’re a fan of Poppy Playtime’s horror that centers itself around haunted children’s toys, then there may be another mascot horror game just for you: Tattletail. This game sees the player needing to complete tasks to take care of their Furby-like toy while the Mama toy stalks them through their house. This creates a tense atmosphere where the player wants nothing more than for their toy to be quiet as its constant crying will give away their location to the monster.
Tattletail has also gained the respect of many gamers by knowing when to stop and leave the stage. Seeing a developer release a single well-liked game and then refrain from churning out merch and sequels is to be admired.
5Choo-Choo Charles
Chugging Along with Terror
Two Star Games
August 09, 2025
PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series S|X, Nintendo Switch, PC
Next up on the list is 2022’s Choo-Choo Charles. While many mascot horror games rely on the tried and tested formula of sticking the player in some sort of abandoned facility, there are a select few that try something grander and more unique. This title in particular has a fantastic concept where the player must navigate their train across an island, gathering resources while a spider-like train chases and stalks their every move.
10 Least Scary Horror Games for Beginners
Games for when you want to be scared…but not too much.
If you are in search of a mascot horror game similar to Poppy Playtime but with a much scarier creature design and a larger focus on exploring a strange world, then perhaps you should give Choo-Choo Charles a chance and chug along those tracks.
4Baldi’s Basics in Education and Learning
The Horrors of Education
Micah McGonagall
Basically, Games!
Release date
June 23, 2025
Baldi’s Basics is a heartwarming example of how even a small project made for a game jam can become a beloved title and still be talked about online for years to come. This horror parody of old educational titles is equal parts fun and humorous. The game even features an evil much more horrifying than any other horror title: math problems!
While the gameplay of Baldi’s Basics is much more inspired by early 2010s indie horror titles like Slender, there is still plenty here for fans of modern mascot horror games like Poppy Playtime to enjoy as you navigate your way through school hallways trying to find quizzes as the very angry teacher begins to close in on you faster and faster. With the official release of the game occurring in 2020, you have no excuse not to try this interesting moment in mascot horror history.
3Spooky’s Jump Scare Mansion
Hang on to your seat
Lag Studios
July 12, 2025
PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, PC
If your preferred style of horror is running from jump scares, then you must consider playing Spooky’s Jump Scare Mansion, the ultimate deconstruction and reconstruction of this trope. Having a game like Spooky showing how the trope can still work effectively is greatly appreciated. The game has stood the test of time too, staying in the public consciousness and even receiving anHD Remaster
The game begins by throwing cardboard stands with crude drawings of monsters no different from those one would expect to see in games like Garten of Banban before slowly progressing into more advanced horror parodies and chases, showcasing how the true art of the jump scare comes from your own sense of control and the tension of trying to avoid failure.
2Five Nights at Freddy’s
Created a Genre
Scott Cawthon
June 14, 2025
PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, Android, IOS, PC
Placing second on the list is the mascot horror title which caused the subgenre to explode into the mainstream:Five Nights at Freddy’s. These games and their gameplay loop of trying to survive several in-game hours as animatronic mascots try to break in have more than won the hearts of gamers. With 13 games currently released, you’ll have hours upon hours of time to sink into this series.
Every Mainline Five Nights At Freddy’s Game, Ranked
Celebrating a decade of Five Nights at Freddy’s with a look at its best titles.
Five Nights at Freddy’s: Security Breach in particular may be appealing to Poppy Playtime fansas it features a large mall-like location to explore in 3D just like Poppy.
Five Nights at Freddy’s has reigned as the king of mascot horror for over a decade now, which is precisely why it isn’t landing at the top of this list. If you are looking into the mascot horror genre and games similar to Poppy Playtime, then you’ve likely already played at least one FNAF game. Thus, the number one spot on this list will instead go to a title you may not know of.
1My Friendly Neighborhood
Mascot Horror at Its Best
John & Evan Szymanski
June 07, 2025
The mascot horror subgenre’s usual bread and butter is placing the player in an abandoned location that was once home to children’s entertainment. Poppy Playtime and half of the games on this list center themselves around that. However, very few of them are able to do so as well asMy Friendly Neighborhood. This game sets itself in a Sesame Street-styled studio where the player is chased down by freaky puppets.
What sets My Friendly Neighborhood apart from other games on this list is simply how well-made it is. From the puppet designs to the areas you must explore to the actual gameplay mechanics, everything about this game feels well-made.
Excellent titles like My Friendly Neighborhood remind us all why this genre became beloved in the first place. If you are a fan of games like Poppy Playtime and want an expertly made experience in the same genre, then consider picking up My Friendly Neighborhood when you have a chance.
10 Short Horror Games You Can Play in One Night
If a gamer wanted to stack their October to the brim with plenty of short horror games, where would they even start?
